Korean J Hematol 2010; 45(4):
Published online December 31, 2010
https://doi.org/10.5045/kjh.2010.45.4.224
© The Korean Society of Hematology
Department of Pediatrics, Pediatric Blood and Marrow Transplant Program and Department of Immunology, Duke University, Durham, USA.
Correspondence to : Correspondence to Paul Szabolcs, M.D. Pediatric Blood and Marrow Transplant Program, Box 3350, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27705, USA. Tel: +1-919-668-1122, Fax: +1-919-668-1180, szabo001@mc.duke.edu
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Despite significant recent advances in the applicability and outcome following unrelated cord blood transplantation (UCBT), infections remain a major cause of mortality associated with poor immune recovery in the first 6 months after UCBT. Enhanced immune reconstitution not only could improve survival by reduced transplant related mortality, but may also favorably impact on relapse incidence by improved graft-versus-leukemia effects. This review will summarize our current understanding of the biology of immune recovery post-UCBT with an emphasis on adaptive T cell dependent immunity. New efforts to boost immunity will be also highlighted including our own laboratory, where ex vivo T cell expansion is pursued towards adoptive immunotherapy.
Keywords Cord blood stem cell transplantation, Opportunistic infection, Immune reconstitution, Adoptive immunotherapy, Graft vs leukemia effect
Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) has emerged over the past 50 years as a life-saving therapy for many human diseases. Although the first reports of successful transplantation described children with inherited immune deficiency disorders, one with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) [1], and another with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) [2], most recipients of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT) are adults and suffer from acquired disorders; leukemia, lymphoma, or aplastic anemia. Regardless of the underlying disease, from the beginning of HSCT, it became apparent that adoptive transfer of healthy marrow and the progeny of donor bone marrow derived hematopoietic stem cells can lead to full reconstitution of the immune system. Among the most significant advances in HSCT over the past decades have been explorations into the use of alternate hematopoietic grafts, to include allogeneic unrelated umbilical cord blood [3-5]. Cord blood (CB) is a by-product from childbirth that historically had been discarded. Experimental studies demonstrated that CB is enriched in primitive hematopoietic progenitors compared with adult bone marrow (BM) and mobilized peripheral blood stem cell grafts (PBSC), reviewed in [6]. Notably, long-term engrafting cells are almost eightfold enriched among CB CD34+ cells compared to those in CD34+ cells from PBSC. Moreover, CB-derived CD34+ progenitors display a ~15-fold higher multilineage proliferative capacity [7]. These biological features could explain the unexpected clinical finding that despite a slower pace of myeloid engraftment after CB transplantation there is a higher prevalence of early progenitors in the marrow space in those children who were given CB as opposed to BM transplant [8].
CB as a hematopoietic graft was first used in 1989 for a child with severe Fanconi anemia [9]. Since 1993, when the first ever unrelated cord blood transplant (UCBT) was performed at Duke University [10], >20,000 such transplants are estimated to have been performed worldwide [11]. The increasing use of CB in the unrelated donor setting is partially explained by the following significant findings. UCBT apparently offers a similar [12] or reduced risk [13] of severe graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) permitting a less stringent criteria for HLA matching, reviewed in [14].
Although UCBT is a life-saving form of HSCT, it is limited by the high incidence of opportunistic infections (OI), most of which are viral. OI is the major cause of transplant-related mortality during the first 6 months after UCBT, and is caused by delays in immune reconstitution. Immune reconstitution is a highly complex process influenced by both graft (e.g. cell dose, histocompatibility, donor serology) and recipient-related factors (age, previous therapy, conditioning regimen, past infectious exposures, etc). Adaptive immunity is the cumulative effect of a network of phenotypically distinct and highly specialized leukocyte subpopulations. Antigen presenting dendritic cell (DC), effector, memory, and regulatory lymphocyte subsets are the principal players of this network. Instructional signals from the innate immune system shape the quality and net effect of antigen-specific immunity.
While attaining normal ranges of specific leukocyte subsets have been used extensively in the literature, protection from clinical infections is the best surrogate marker of successful immune reconstitution.
Infection-related mortality (IRM) is the primary or secondary cause of death (with or without another major cause such as GVHD) in ≥50% of deaths after UCBT with the majority of them occurring in the first 100 days [14-17]. A classic report from the International Bone Marrow Transplant Registry (IBMTR) highlights the unique features of infection incidence after UCBT. Outcome after transplantation was analyzed between recipients of either CB (N=150) or from marrow that was from HLA-matched (N=367) or mismatched for 1 HLA antigen (N=83) [18]. IRM within 100 days after transplantation was significantly higher among recipients of mismatched CB than among recipients of either HLA-matched marrow or mismatched marrow (45%, 21%, and 24%, respectively;
Immunoablation is an obligatory consequence of most myeloablative preparative regimens. While as a whole the innate immune system appears to recover rapidly, within weeks after HCT, the recovery of functional B and T lymphocytes (adaptive immunity) is far more difficult to achieve [22, 23]. The first wave of T cells emerging in the lymphopenic host are peripherally expanding T lymphocytes that were infused with the graft representing the thymic-independent pathway [24]. However, the antigen-driven expansion of peripheral T cells leads to a limited and skewed T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire [24]. Several weeks/months later a second wave of T cells emerge developing from donor-derived common lymphocyte progenitors (CLP) as the result of de novo thymopoiesis. In the absence of significant GVHD, this thymic-dependent pathway [25, 26] is solely responsible for a fully diverse T cell repertoire. Interestingly, by 2 years after HCT higher TCR diversity may be attained in CB recipients than in recipients of BMT [27] indicating the existence of an efficient thymic-dependent pathway.
CB contains significantly higher absolute numbers of T, NK, and B lymphocytes than adult peripheral blood (PB) or even marrow [28-31]. However, functional differences are more critical compared to numerical ones. Despite an overlapping CD45RA+/CD28+/CD27+ phenotype, CB T cells are fundamentally different from 'naïve' adult T cells mostly because they demonstrate a relative Th2/Tc2 bias. Multiple tiers of Th1/Tc1 suppressing factors exist at the maternal-fetal interface; IL-10 secreted by cytotrophoblasts [32], reduced local Tryptophan levels [33], increased progesterone levels [34] and other placental factors (IL-4, PGE2), reviewed in [35]. This immunoregulatory network could be viewed as part of an evolutionary adaptation to permit survival and avoid rejection of the fetus. Fas-ligand expression at the maternal-fetal interface may eliminate T cells activated despite these factors above [36]. The exuberant production of IL-13 primarily by CD8+ T cells [37] is in sharp contrast with lower IFNγ production that persists even after stimulation via CD3/CD28 signaling and exogenous IL-2 [37]. This is a consequence of differential patterns of methylation of the IFNγ promoter [38]. Independently, impaired APC function of neonatal/CB dendritic cells (DC) restricts the potential for optimal Th1 cell responses in neonates due to their low IL-12 expression [39-41]. Despite these limits, there is evidence that intrauterine viral infections (e.g. cytomegalovirus, CMV) could generate partial Th1 immune responses [35], though persistent and selective deficiency of antiviral Th1 CD4+ T cell is documented into early childhood [42]. The reduced capacity of bulk CB mononuclear cells to secrete cytokines and lymphokines has been reported to affect GM-CSF, M-CSF, IL-4, IL-8, IL-12, IL-15, and IL-18, reviewed in [43, 44]. There is reduced expression of NFATc2 (nuclear factor of activated T cells c2), a critical transcription factor necessary for up-regulation of these and other cytokines known to amplify T-cell responses. The relative cytolytic deficiency of CB T cells is associated with absent expression of granzymes and perforin [45], essential for the control of viral and other pathogens. Nevertheless, as Kyung-Duk Park in my laboratory demonstrated [46],
Although mitogenic proliferative responses may already reach normal range in children 6-9 months after UCBT, T cell reconstitution is gradual and typically does not reach age-appropriate numbers before 9 months. Meanwhile, T cell recovery in adults typically extends beyond the first year, presumably related to the inferior output of TREC+ naïve T cells in older recipients [52]. Notably, NK cell recovery is prompt both in numbers and function in both adults and children by the first 2 months similar to recipients of BM [53-55]. Significant B lymphocyte recovery starts ~2-4 months after transplant and according to a recent analysis of a combined dataset from Marseille and Lyon, they may recover relatively fast, by ~3 months after CBT compared to ~6 months post-unrelated donor BMT [55].
Although the incidence of life-threatening viral infections is high in the first 6 months after UCBT likely reflecting deficits in T cell numbers or function, when monitored beyond 9 months post-transplant the speed of T cell recovery seems to be at least comparable [56] to or even better than that seen after unrelated BMT, [31, 53, 57]. Investigators from the Cord Blood Transplantation Study (COBLT) analyzed antigen-specific proliferation after UCBT [21]. Children with malignancies were longitudinally tested over the first 3 years post transplant for herpes virus specific responses (HSV, VZV, CMV). Approximately 43% of the patients studied eventually developed a positive T-lymphocyte proliferative response to at least one herpes virus at some point over the 3 year observational period. In a few, proliferative responses developed as early as within the first 30-50 days, indicating that naïve T lymphocytes transferred in the graft can give rise to antigen-specific T-lymphocyte immunity before thymic recovery [21]. Surprisingly, patients with a proliferative response at any time in the first 3 years to any of the herpes viruses had a lower probability of leukemia relapse and a higher overall survival [21]. One may speculate that the superior proliferative T cell response represents a powerful surrogate marker for functional immune reconstitution leading to more effective graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) activity. However, the development and kinetics of protective antigen-specific function was not evaluable [58].
Investigators at the University of Minnesota retrospectively evaluated the impact of overall lymphocyte recovery in 360 consecutive patients with hematologic malignancy utilizing data from standard hemocytometers [59]. Patients underwent UCBT between 2001 and 2007. In multivariate analysis, an absolute lymphocyte count (ALC) of >200×106/L at day 30 (N=73) after myeloablative conditioning was associated with superior 2-year overall survival (OS) (73% vs. 61%;
Over the past several years the Szabolcs lab has studied the reconstitution of immunity in the immediate post-UCBT period (prior to thymic recovery) in >150 pediatric recipients of single unit UCB at Duke University to identify surrogate immune markers for those at risk for opportunistic infections (OI).
Several graft and patient-specific variables were identified as significant factors, when the laboratory measurements of DC and T cell reconstitution were analyzed. To determine the impact of patient and graft-specific factors on 6-month post-UCBT OI-related mortality, we reviewed all consecutive pediatric UCB recipients transplanted at Duke University Medical Center between June 1999 and Oct 2005 to overlap with the immune monitoring studies [60]. Three hundred thirty pediatric recipients of single UCB grafts were identified. Those receiving a second transplant for primary graft failure were excluded. Two hundred twenty of the 330 patients (67%) were alive at 6 months (Fig. 1). Of those who died by 6 months, 58% were identified with OI (viral, fungal, protozoal infections) implicated as a cause of death. Those who died prior to 6 months and for whom OI was not implicated as a cause of death were omitted from the study dataset, resulting in 284 patients.
Multivariate modeling revealed that a significantly greater probability of 6-month OI-related death was associated with CMV-positive serology, greater HLA mismatch, and older age. Higher total graft cell dose, including CD34+ progenitor cell dose and CD3+ cell dose were each associated with lower probability of death due to OI at 6 months [61]. Here we demonstrated for the first time the protective immunity afforded by expansion and functional contribution of post-thymic T cells infused with the graft prior to the recovery of the "central"
To identify patients who were at increased risk for developing OI in the first 100 days, a prospective cross-sectional study has been conducted at day +50 post-UCBT [62], with the latest analysis extended to 111 patients. Utilizing Trucount™ methodology, 4-color surface and intracellular (ic) FACS was employed to accurately enumerate and characterize lymphocyte and DC subsets [30, 63, 64]. All patients received myeloablative conditioning regimes (TBI/CY, Bu/CY, Bu/MEL, TBI/MEL) and equine ATG at 30 mg/kg/day between day -3 to day -1. All received identical GVHD prophylaxis consisting of Cyclosporine A plus steroids, slowly tapered after day +21 in the absence of ≥grade II aGVHD. Various degree of cellular reconstitution is noted for most immune cells except for the absence of B lymphocytes. However, immune reconstitution varied widely.
Table 1 lists those immune parameters that remain significant predictors for the presence of
With another study we aimed to gain insight into the fate and maturational biology of adoptively transferred naive T cells in the lymphopenic hosts even prior to the onset of OI to develop predictive models for OI incidence in the first 100 days. Blood was obtained at a median 18 days post-UCBT if the WBC exceeded 400/mm3. Circulating T-cell subsets and DC counts were monitored. Since our last report [65], we have analyzed 76 patients at a median age of 62 months with at least 12 months follow-up. Forty four patients (58%) presented
In those who developed OI, significantly higher proportion of the circulating T cells were CD8+ (40% vs. 28%,
In conclusion, in the immediate post-transplant lymphopenic period extensive T cell proliferation via peripheral expansion leads to major immunophenotypic alterations accompanied by a gradual loss of the original naïve phenotype. In parallel, new T cell subsets emerge displaying a phenotype associated with antigenic stimulation [66]. We hypothesize that in patients who will develop OI, even clinically undetectable levels of virus could induce phenotypic acquisition of Th1/Tc1 cytotoxic effector profile.
Recently, we and others have demonstrated the feasibility of
In the most current study [74], we tested and confirmed our hypotheses, that interleukin-7 (IL-7) acting in concert with a new, clinical grade CD3/CD28 costimulatory bead and IL-2, would not only enhance
Purified T cells obtained from frozen/thawed cord blood specimens were split and cultured in parallel with and without IL-7. Matched pair analysis demonstrated significantly more viable T cells when IL-7 was added to IL-2 in the medium leading to an average of 165 fold T cell expansion (Fig. 3A). Following 14 days of expansion, striking dilution of TCR excision circles was noted as the sjTREC content in CD3+ T cells was depleted by ~2log in both culture conditions as compared to the starting population of pre-expansion CB T cells (Fig. 3B), irrespective of IL-7 exposure. Significantly more viable CD45 bright T lymphocytes were identified in cultures supplanted with IL-7 (71±10%) compared to cultures with IL-2 alone (46±15%) As determined by ic activated Caspase-3 expression and 7-AAD staining, there were significantly fewer T cells undergoing active apoptosis in the presence of IL-7 (median 4% versus 8%) (Fig. 4B). The anti-apoptotic effect of IL-7 was evident in both CD4+ and CD8+ subsets. To test T cell survival promoting effects of IL-7 beyond the
Once we have demonstrated the salutary effects of IL-7 on T cell viability, expansion, and overall T cell receptor diversity, we sought to determine its impact on surface and intracellular phenotype and overall T cell function as measured by cytokine secretion profile and cytotoxicity. Despite undergoing several cycles of cell division triggered by IL-2 + IL-7 in concert with TCR and CD28 co-stimulation, significantly more CB T cells retained the naïve starting phenotype, CD45RA+/CD62L+ in the IL-7-containing condition (90±5%) compared to cells cultured in IL-2 alone (73±14%,
CD3/CD28 co-stimulation with ClinExVivo™ Dynabeads® in this series of experiments enhanced in a larger fraction of post-expansion T cells the capacity for intracellular expression of IFNγ, TNFα, and Granzyme B than we previously reported using different artificial-APC beads [67]. Nevertheless, despite the potential for an increase in alloreactivity [78] after the more robust expansion in the presence of IL-7, the expanded progeny lacked cytotoxicity against a highly immunogenic (CD40+, CD80+, CD86+) EBV+ allogeneic lymphoblastoid cell line (IM9) (N=7), or recipient fibroblasts (N=2), despite a week long pre-sensitization prior to performing the CTL assay (Fig. 6). Interestingly, absent cytotoxicity coincided with low expression of 4-1BB/CD137, CD40L, and perforin. Taken together, these features support a favorable safety profile of 'day 14' ClinExVivo™ expanded T cells with reduced likelihood for inducing GVHD
Donor leukocyte infusion with 'day 14' ClinExVivo™ +IL-2 +IL-7 expanded T cells generated from the originally infused CB graft could alleviate post-transplant lymphopenia and qualitative T cell defects until thymic regeneration could contribute new T cells. However, such DLI would be antigen non-specific and will require microbial and/or tumor antigens to in vivo prime infused T cells in the transplant recipients. In a series of experiments, we evaluated the potential of 'day 14' CD3/CD28-costimulated/expanded T cells to undergo
UCBT is a life-saving form of HCT, however, it is limited by the high incidence of OI, most of which are viral. OI is the major cause of transplant related mortality during the first 6 months after UCBT, and is caused by delays in immune reconstitution. For several months, until recovery of the thymus is restored to support
Kaplan-Meier curve of survival (months) after UCBT in 330 consecutive patients. Death related to opportunistic infections (OI ) is the major cause of failure, most occurring
Flow cytometry profile of the expanded T cell progeny±IL-7. Surface and intracellular (ic) FACS characterization was performed as shown previously [30, 64, 67]. The relative size of T cell subsets in each quadrant is expressed as the percentage of total viable T cells, see Table 1 for
Absent cytotoxicity of the expanded CB T cells against allogeneic targets irrespective of±IL-7. Effector T cells were obtained from PBL of healthy volunteers as positive controls and compared with CD3/28 co-stimulated CB T cells±IL-7. First, effectors were primed/sensitized against a highly immunogeneic (HLA-DR+, CD40+, CD80+, CD86+) IM9 cell line for 7-9 days at 1:1 to 1:3 responder:stimulator ratio, then re-exposed to fresh BATDA®-loaded IM9 targets at the indicated E:T ratios for 2 & 3 h. Europium release was measured by the Delfia® EuTDA cytotoxicity assay [67] and the calculated percent specific cytotoxicity is presented on the Y-axis. Representative of 7 experiments.
Leukemia-specific CTL can be
Table 1 Continuous variables of immunity associated with OI incidence in the first 100 days. Measurements in the 'Day +50 study' group.
Confounders tested: Race, age, gender, weight, CMV status, HLA mismatch, malignancy, TBI, GVHD, High Dose steroid pulse (yes, no), Anti-CD25/Daclizumab pulse (yes, no), infused total cell dose/kg, CD34+cell/kg, CD3+ T cell dose/kg.
Korean J Hematol 2010; 45(4): 224-235
Published online December 31, 2010 https://doi.org/10.5045/kjh.2010.45.4.224
Copyright © The Korean Society of Hematology.
Paul Szabolcs*
Department of Pediatrics, Pediatric Blood and Marrow Transplant Program and Department of Immunology, Duke University, Durham, USA.
Correspondence to: Correspondence to Paul Szabolcs, M.D. Pediatric Blood and Marrow Transplant Program, Box 3350, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27705, USA. Tel: +1-919-668-1122, Fax: +1-919-668-1180, szabo001@mc.duke.edu
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Despite significant recent advances in the applicability and outcome following unrelated cord blood transplantation (UCBT), infections remain a major cause of mortality associated with poor immune recovery in the first 6 months after UCBT. Enhanced immune reconstitution not only could improve survival by reduced transplant related mortality, but may also favorably impact on relapse incidence by improved graft-versus-leukemia effects. This review will summarize our current understanding of the biology of immune recovery post-UCBT with an emphasis on adaptive T cell dependent immunity. New efforts to boost immunity will be also highlighted including our own laboratory, where ex vivo T cell expansion is pursued towards adoptive immunotherapy.
Keywords: Cord blood stem cell transplantation, Opportunistic infection, Immune reconstitution, Adoptive immunotherapy, Graft vs leukemia effect
Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) has emerged over the past 50 years as a life-saving therapy for many human diseases. Although the first reports of successful transplantation described children with inherited immune deficiency disorders, one with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) [1], and another with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) [2], most recipients of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT) are adults and suffer from acquired disorders; leukemia, lymphoma, or aplastic anemia. Regardless of the underlying disease, from the beginning of HSCT, it became apparent that adoptive transfer of healthy marrow and the progeny of donor bone marrow derived hematopoietic stem cells can lead to full reconstitution of the immune system. Among the most significant advances in HSCT over the past decades have been explorations into the use of alternate hematopoietic grafts, to include allogeneic unrelated umbilical cord blood [3-5]. Cord blood (CB) is a by-product from childbirth that historically had been discarded. Experimental studies demonstrated that CB is enriched in primitive hematopoietic progenitors compared with adult bone marrow (BM) and mobilized peripheral blood stem cell grafts (PBSC), reviewed in [6]. Notably, long-term engrafting cells are almost eightfold enriched among CB CD34+ cells compared to those in CD34+ cells from PBSC. Moreover, CB-derived CD34+ progenitors display a ~15-fold higher multilineage proliferative capacity [7]. These biological features could explain the unexpected clinical finding that despite a slower pace of myeloid engraftment after CB transplantation there is a higher prevalence of early progenitors in the marrow space in those children who were given CB as opposed to BM transplant [8].
CB as a hematopoietic graft was first used in 1989 for a child with severe Fanconi anemia [9]. Since 1993, when the first ever unrelated cord blood transplant (UCBT) was performed at Duke University [10], >20,000 such transplants are estimated to have been performed worldwide [11]. The increasing use of CB in the unrelated donor setting is partially explained by the following significant findings. UCBT apparently offers a similar [12] or reduced risk [13] of severe graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) permitting a less stringent criteria for HLA matching, reviewed in [14].
Although UCBT is a life-saving form of HSCT, it is limited by the high incidence of opportunistic infections (OI), most of which are viral. OI is the major cause of transplant-related mortality during the first 6 months after UCBT, and is caused by delays in immune reconstitution. Immune reconstitution is a highly complex process influenced by both graft (e.g. cell dose, histocompatibility, donor serology) and recipient-related factors (age, previous therapy, conditioning regimen, past infectious exposures, etc). Adaptive immunity is the cumulative effect of a network of phenotypically distinct and highly specialized leukocyte subpopulations. Antigen presenting dendritic cell (DC), effector, memory, and regulatory lymphocyte subsets are the principal players of this network. Instructional signals from the innate immune system shape the quality and net effect of antigen-specific immunity.
While attaining normal ranges of specific leukocyte subsets have been used extensively in the literature, protection from clinical infections is the best surrogate marker of successful immune reconstitution.
Infection-related mortality (IRM) is the primary or secondary cause of death (with or without another major cause such as GVHD) in ≥50% of deaths after UCBT with the majority of them occurring in the first 100 days [14-17]. A classic report from the International Bone Marrow Transplant Registry (IBMTR) highlights the unique features of infection incidence after UCBT. Outcome after transplantation was analyzed between recipients of either CB (N=150) or from marrow that was from HLA-matched (N=367) or mismatched for 1 HLA antigen (N=83) [18]. IRM within 100 days after transplantation was significantly higher among recipients of mismatched CB than among recipients of either HLA-matched marrow or mismatched marrow (45%, 21%, and 24%, respectively;
Immunoablation is an obligatory consequence of most myeloablative preparative regimens. While as a whole the innate immune system appears to recover rapidly, within weeks after HCT, the recovery of functional B and T lymphocytes (adaptive immunity) is far more difficult to achieve [22, 23]. The first wave of T cells emerging in the lymphopenic host are peripherally expanding T lymphocytes that were infused with the graft representing the thymic-independent pathway [24]. However, the antigen-driven expansion of peripheral T cells leads to a limited and skewed T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire [24]. Several weeks/months later a second wave of T cells emerge developing from donor-derived common lymphocyte progenitors (CLP) as the result of de novo thymopoiesis. In the absence of significant GVHD, this thymic-dependent pathway [25, 26] is solely responsible for a fully diverse T cell repertoire. Interestingly, by 2 years after HCT higher TCR diversity may be attained in CB recipients than in recipients of BMT [27] indicating the existence of an efficient thymic-dependent pathway.
CB contains significantly higher absolute numbers of T, NK, and B lymphocytes than adult peripheral blood (PB) or even marrow [28-31]. However, functional differences are more critical compared to numerical ones. Despite an overlapping CD45RA+/CD28+/CD27+ phenotype, CB T cells are fundamentally different from 'naïve' adult T cells mostly because they demonstrate a relative Th2/Tc2 bias. Multiple tiers of Th1/Tc1 suppressing factors exist at the maternal-fetal interface; IL-10 secreted by cytotrophoblasts [32], reduced local Tryptophan levels [33], increased progesterone levels [34] and other placental factors (IL-4, PGE2), reviewed in [35]. This immunoregulatory network could be viewed as part of an evolutionary adaptation to permit survival and avoid rejection of the fetus. Fas-ligand expression at the maternal-fetal interface may eliminate T cells activated despite these factors above [36]. The exuberant production of IL-13 primarily by CD8+ T cells [37] is in sharp contrast with lower IFNγ production that persists even after stimulation via CD3/CD28 signaling and exogenous IL-2 [37]. This is a consequence of differential patterns of methylation of the IFNγ promoter [38]. Independently, impaired APC function of neonatal/CB dendritic cells (DC) restricts the potential for optimal Th1 cell responses in neonates due to their low IL-12 expression [39-41]. Despite these limits, there is evidence that intrauterine viral infections (e.g. cytomegalovirus, CMV) could generate partial Th1 immune responses [35], though persistent and selective deficiency of antiviral Th1 CD4+ T cell is documented into early childhood [42]. The reduced capacity of bulk CB mononuclear cells to secrete cytokines and lymphokines has been reported to affect GM-CSF, M-CSF, IL-4, IL-8, IL-12, IL-15, and IL-18, reviewed in [43, 44]. There is reduced expression of NFATc2 (nuclear factor of activated T cells c2), a critical transcription factor necessary for up-regulation of these and other cytokines known to amplify T-cell responses. The relative cytolytic deficiency of CB T cells is associated with absent expression of granzymes and perforin [45], essential for the control of viral and other pathogens. Nevertheless, as Kyung-Duk Park in my laboratory demonstrated [46],
Although mitogenic proliferative responses may already reach normal range in children 6-9 months after UCBT, T cell reconstitution is gradual and typically does not reach age-appropriate numbers before 9 months. Meanwhile, T cell recovery in adults typically extends beyond the first year, presumably related to the inferior output of TREC+ naïve T cells in older recipients [52]. Notably, NK cell recovery is prompt both in numbers and function in both adults and children by the first 2 months similar to recipients of BM [53-55]. Significant B lymphocyte recovery starts ~2-4 months after transplant and according to a recent analysis of a combined dataset from Marseille and Lyon, they may recover relatively fast, by ~3 months after CBT compared to ~6 months post-unrelated donor BMT [55].
Although the incidence of life-threatening viral infections is high in the first 6 months after UCBT likely reflecting deficits in T cell numbers or function, when monitored beyond 9 months post-transplant the speed of T cell recovery seems to be at least comparable [56] to or even better than that seen after unrelated BMT, [31, 53, 57]. Investigators from the Cord Blood Transplantation Study (COBLT) analyzed antigen-specific proliferation after UCBT [21]. Children with malignancies were longitudinally tested over the first 3 years post transplant for herpes virus specific responses (HSV, VZV, CMV). Approximately 43% of the patients studied eventually developed a positive T-lymphocyte proliferative response to at least one herpes virus at some point over the 3 year observational period. In a few, proliferative responses developed as early as within the first 30-50 days, indicating that naïve T lymphocytes transferred in the graft can give rise to antigen-specific T-lymphocyte immunity before thymic recovery [21]. Surprisingly, patients with a proliferative response at any time in the first 3 years to any of the herpes viruses had a lower probability of leukemia relapse and a higher overall survival [21]. One may speculate that the superior proliferative T cell response represents a powerful surrogate marker for functional immune reconstitution leading to more effective graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) activity. However, the development and kinetics of protective antigen-specific function was not evaluable [58].
Investigators at the University of Minnesota retrospectively evaluated the impact of overall lymphocyte recovery in 360 consecutive patients with hematologic malignancy utilizing data from standard hemocytometers [59]. Patients underwent UCBT between 2001 and 2007. In multivariate analysis, an absolute lymphocyte count (ALC) of >200×106/L at day 30 (N=73) after myeloablative conditioning was associated with superior 2-year overall survival (OS) (73% vs. 61%;
Over the past several years the Szabolcs lab has studied the reconstitution of immunity in the immediate post-UCBT period (prior to thymic recovery) in >150 pediatric recipients of single unit UCB at Duke University to identify surrogate immune markers for those at risk for opportunistic infections (OI).
Several graft and patient-specific variables were identified as significant factors, when the laboratory measurements of DC and T cell reconstitution were analyzed. To determine the impact of patient and graft-specific factors on 6-month post-UCBT OI-related mortality, we reviewed all consecutive pediatric UCB recipients transplanted at Duke University Medical Center between June 1999 and Oct 2005 to overlap with the immune monitoring studies [60]. Three hundred thirty pediatric recipients of single UCB grafts were identified. Those receiving a second transplant for primary graft failure were excluded. Two hundred twenty of the 330 patients (67%) were alive at 6 months (Fig. 1). Of those who died by 6 months, 58% were identified with OI (viral, fungal, protozoal infections) implicated as a cause of death. Those who died prior to 6 months and for whom OI was not implicated as a cause of death were omitted from the study dataset, resulting in 284 patients.
Multivariate modeling revealed that a significantly greater probability of 6-month OI-related death was associated with CMV-positive serology, greater HLA mismatch, and older age. Higher total graft cell dose, including CD34+ progenitor cell dose and CD3+ cell dose were each associated with lower probability of death due to OI at 6 months [61]. Here we demonstrated for the first time the protective immunity afforded by expansion and functional contribution of post-thymic T cells infused with the graft prior to the recovery of the "central"
To identify patients who were at increased risk for developing OI in the first 100 days, a prospective cross-sectional study has been conducted at day +50 post-UCBT [62], with the latest analysis extended to 111 patients. Utilizing Trucount™ methodology, 4-color surface and intracellular (ic) FACS was employed to accurately enumerate and characterize lymphocyte and DC subsets [30, 63, 64]. All patients received myeloablative conditioning regimes (TBI/CY, Bu/CY, Bu/MEL, TBI/MEL) and equine ATG at 30 mg/kg/day between day -3 to day -1. All received identical GVHD prophylaxis consisting of Cyclosporine A plus steroids, slowly tapered after day +21 in the absence of ≥grade II aGVHD. Various degree of cellular reconstitution is noted for most immune cells except for the absence of B lymphocytes. However, immune reconstitution varied widely.
Table 1 lists those immune parameters that remain significant predictors for the presence of
With another study we aimed to gain insight into the fate and maturational biology of adoptively transferred naive T cells in the lymphopenic hosts even prior to the onset of OI to develop predictive models for OI incidence in the first 100 days. Blood was obtained at a median 18 days post-UCBT if the WBC exceeded 400/mm3. Circulating T-cell subsets and DC counts were monitored. Since our last report [65], we have analyzed 76 patients at a median age of 62 months with at least 12 months follow-up. Forty four patients (58%) presented
In those who developed OI, significantly higher proportion of the circulating T cells were CD8+ (40% vs. 28%,
In conclusion, in the immediate post-transplant lymphopenic period extensive T cell proliferation via peripheral expansion leads to major immunophenotypic alterations accompanied by a gradual loss of the original naïve phenotype. In parallel, new T cell subsets emerge displaying a phenotype associated with antigenic stimulation [66]. We hypothesize that in patients who will develop OI, even clinically undetectable levels of virus could induce phenotypic acquisition of Th1/Tc1 cytotoxic effector profile.
Recently, we and others have demonstrated the feasibility of
In the most current study [74], we tested and confirmed our hypotheses, that interleukin-7 (IL-7) acting in concert with a new, clinical grade CD3/CD28 costimulatory bead and IL-2, would not only enhance
Purified T cells obtained from frozen/thawed cord blood specimens were split and cultured in parallel with and without IL-7. Matched pair analysis demonstrated significantly more viable T cells when IL-7 was added to IL-2 in the medium leading to an average of 165 fold T cell expansion (Fig. 3A). Following 14 days of expansion, striking dilution of TCR excision circles was noted as the sjTREC content in CD3+ T cells was depleted by ~2log in both culture conditions as compared to the starting population of pre-expansion CB T cells (Fig. 3B), irrespective of IL-7 exposure. Significantly more viable CD45 bright T lymphocytes were identified in cultures supplanted with IL-7 (71±10%) compared to cultures with IL-2 alone (46±15%) As determined by ic activated Caspase-3 expression and 7-AAD staining, there were significantly fewer T cells undergoing active apoptosis in the presence of IL-7 (median 4% versus 8%) (Fig. 4B). The anti-apoptotic effect of IL-7 was evident in both CD4+ and CD8+ subsets. To test T cell survival promoting effects of IL-7 beyond the
Once we have demonstrated the salutary effects of IL-7 on T cell viability, expansion, and overall T cell receptor diversity, we sought to determine its impact on surface and intracellular phenotype and overall T cell function as measured by cytokine secretion profile and cytotoxicity. Despite undergoing several cycles of cell division triggered by IL-2 + IL-7 in concert with TCR and CD28 co-stimulation, significantly more CB T cells retained the naïve starting phenotype, CD45RA+/CD62L+ in the IL-7-containing condition (90±5%) compared to cells cultured in IL-2 alone (73±14%,
CD3/CD28 co-stimulation with ClinExVivo™ Dynabeads® in this series of experiments enhanced in a larger fraction of post-expansion T cells the capacity for intracellular expression of IFNγ, TNFα, and Granzyme B than we previously reported using different artificial-APC beads [67]. Nevertheless, despite the potential for an increase in alloreactivity [78] after the more robust expansion in the presence of IL-7, the expanded progeny lacked cytotoxicity against a highly immunogenic (CD40+, CD80+, CD86+) EBV+ allogeneic lymphoblastoid cell line (IM9) (N=7), or recipient fibroblasts (N=2), despite a week long pre-sensitization prior to performing the CTL assay (Fig. 6). Interestingly, absent cytotoxicity coincided with low expression of 4-1BB/CD137, CD40L, and perforin. Taken together, these features support a favorable safety profile of 'day 14' ClinExVivo™ expanded T cells with reduced likelihood for inducing GVHD
Donor leukocyte infusion with 'day 14' ClinExVivo™ +IL-2 +IL-7 expanded T cells generated from the originally infused CB graft could alleviate post-transplant lymphopenia and qualitative T cell defects until thymic regeneration could contribute new T cells. However, such DLI would be antigen non-specific and will require microbial and/or tumor antigens to in vivo prime infused T cells in the transplant recipients. In a series of experiments, we evaluated the potential of 'day 14' CD3/CD28-costimulated/expanded T cells to undergo
UCBT is a life-saving form of HCT, however, it is limited by the high incidence of OI, most of which are viral. OI is the major cause of transplant related mortality during the first 6 months after UCBT, and is caused by delays in immune reconstitution. For several months, until recovery of the thymus is restored to support
Kaplan-Meier curve of survival (months) after UCBT in 330 consecutive patients. Death related to opportunistic infections (OI ) is the major cause of failure, most occurring
Flow cytometry profile of the expanded T cell progeny±IL-7. Surface and intracellular (ic) FACS characterization was performed as shown previously [30, 64, 67]. The relative size of T cell subsets in each quadrant is expressed as the percentage of total viable T cells, see Table 1 for
Absent cytotoxicity of the expanded CB T cells against allogeneic targets irrespective of±IL-7. Effector T cells were obtained from PBL of healthy volunteers as positive controls and compared with CD3/28 co-stimulated CB T cells±IL-7. First, effectors were primed/sensitized against a highly immunogeneic (HLA-DR+, CD40+, CD80+, CD86+) IM9 cell line for 7-9 days at 1:1 to 1:3 responder:stimulator ratio, then re-exposed to fresh BATDA®-loaded IM9 targets at the indicated E:T ratios for 2 & 3 h. Europium release was measured by the Delfia® EuTDA cytotoxicity assay [67] and the calculated percent specific cytotoxicity is presented on the Y-axis. Representative of 7 experiments.
Leukemia-specific CTL can be
Table 1 . Continuous variables of immunity associated with OI incidence in the first 100 days. Measurements in the 'Day +50 study' group..
Confounders tested: Race, age, gender, weight, CMV status, HLA mismatch, malignancy, TBI, GVHD, High Dose steroid pulse (yes, no), Anti-CD25/Daclizumab pulse (yes, no), infused total cell dose/kg, CD34+cell/kg, CD3+ T cell dose/kg..
Keun Wook Bae, Bo Eun Kim, Kyung Nam Koh, Ho Joon Im, and Jong Jin Seo
Korean J Hematol 2012; 47(1): 44-52Ji hyang Lim, Yong goo Kim, Kyun gja Han, Chang Suk Kang, Won Il Kim, Byung Kee Kim, Sang In Shim, Jong Wook Lee, Woo Sung Min, Chun Choo Kim
Korean J Hematol 1999; 34(3): 366-375
Kaplan-Meier curve of survival (months) after UCBT in 330 consecutive patients. Death related to opportunistic infections (OI ) is the major cause of failure, most occurring
Flow cytometry profile of the expanded T cell progeny±IL-7. Surface and intracellular (ic) FACS characterization was performed as shown previously [30, 64, 67]. The relative size of T cell subsets in each quadrant is expressed as the percentage of total viable T cells, see Table 1 for
Absent cytotoxicity of the expanded CB T cells against allogeneic targets irrespective of±IL-7. Effector T cells were obtained from PBL of healthy volunteers as positive controls and compared with CD3/28 co-stimulated CB T cells±IL-7. First, effectors were primed/sensitized against a highly immunogeneic (HLA-DR+, CD40+, CD80+, CD86+) IM9 cell line for 7-9 days at 1:1 to 1:3 responder:stimulator ratio, then re-exposed to fresh BATDA®-loaded IM9 targets at the indicated E:T ratios for 2 & 3 h. Europium release was measured by the Delfia® EuTDA cytotoxicity assay [67] and the calculated percent specific cytotoxicity is presented on the Y-axis. Representative of 7 experiments.
|@|~(^,^)~|@|Leukemia-specific CTL can be